Discharge is one of the few sexual health symptoms specific enough to narrow things down. It points towards inflammation of the urethra or rectum and therefore towards a fairly short list of organisms. What it cannot do is identify which one, and what people forget is that several of the infections with the most serious consequences produce no discharge whatsoever.
Which infections commonly cause urethral discharge?
Gonorrhoea is the classic cause, typically producing a thick, copious discharge that is white, yellow or green and appears within two to fourteen days of exposure. Chlamydia is the next most common, generally giving a thinner, clearer or cloudy discharge that is most noticeable first thing in the morning, appearing one to three weeks after exposure. Mycoplasma genitalium is increasingly recognised as a cause of persistent urethritis and behaves much like chlamydia. Trichomonas is less common in men in the UK but does occur. Ureaplasma is sometimes found, though its role is debated and it is often present without causing anything.
Does the colour actually tell you anything?
Only loosely. Thick and green or yellow leans towards gonorrhoea, thin and clear leans towards chlamydia or another cause of non-gonococcal urethritis, but the overlap is wide enough that no experienced clinician will commit on appearance. Treating on the basis of colour is how people end up with the wrong antibiotic and a persistent infection. A urine sample or urethral swab gives an answer within days, and some clinics can look at a slide under a microscope during the appointment.
What if there is discharge but tests are negative?
This happens and has a name: non-gonococcal urethritis where no organism is identified. Sometimes the cause is a pathogen not routinely tested for, sometimes it is irritation from soap, spermicide or vigorous friction, and sometimes it is a urinary tract infection. Clinics generally treat it with doxycycline anyway. Persistent symptoms after treatment warrant a return visit and specific testing for Mycoplasma genitalium, which requires different antibiotics and is a common reason a course fails.
What causes rectal discharge?
Rectal gonorrhoea and chlamydia are the usual culprits, producing mucus or pus that is sometimes noticed only as staining. Lymphogranuloma venereum causes a much more purulent and often bloody discharge with significant pain. Herpes and mpox can produce discharge alongside pain and ulceration. Shigella causes diarrhoea rather than discharge as such. Rectal discharge accompanied by severe pain, bleeding or fever deserves an urgent appointment rather than a routine one.
Which infections cause no discharge at all?
This is the more important half of the question. HIV does not cause discharge. Syphilis does not, beyond fluid weeping from a chancre in some cases. Hepatitis A, B and C do not. HPV does not. Herpes causes ulcers rather than discharge in most cases. These are, between them, the infections with the greatest long-term consequences, and none of them can be ruled in or out by looking for discharge. Someone who has been checking for it and finding nothing has learned almost nothing about their HIV or syphilis status.
Is a small amount in the morning normal?
A little clear fluid at the tip of the penis on waking can be normal, particularly after arousal during the night. What is not normal is a persistent discharge that stains underwear, any discharge that is coloured or thick, or any amount accompanied by burning when you urinate. Squeezing the urethra repeatedly to check will itself cause irritation and a small amount of fluid, so it is worth resisting that particular loop.
What should you do about it?
Attend a sexual health clinic rather than a GP where possible, since clinics can take the right swabs from every site and often treat the same day. Do not have sex until you have been assessed, since urethritis is highly transmissible. Ask for a full screen including HIV and syphilis blood tests rather than only investigating the discharge, because the symptom in front of you says nothing at all about the infections that do not cause one.