Receptive anal sex should not be painful. Mild pressure or a stretching sensation at the start is normal and settles as the muscles relax, but sharp pain, burning that persists, or pain that gets worse rather than better is telling you something. Working out which kind you are dealing with is the difference between adjusting your approach and needing to be seen.
The two sphincters
There are two rings of muscle at the anus. The external sphincter is under conscious control and can be relaxed deliberately. The internal sphincter is not: it responds to the autonomic nervous system, which means it tightens when you are anxious, cold, rushed or tense, regardless of what you have decided. This is why willing yourself to relax often fails and why time, warmth and arousal work better than effort. Most pain during entry is this muscle refusing to yield rather than anything structural.
Not enough lubricant
The rectum produces no lubrication of its own, unlike the vagina. Everything has to be added, and more than people expect, reapplied during rather than only at the start. Friction against a dry mucosal surface causes microtears that hurt at the time and for a day or two afterwards, and those tears are also a route for infection. A thicker water-based or silicone-based lubricant is generally better for anal sex than a thin one.
Going too fast
Rushing entry is the most common cause of pain and of the small tears that lead to it. Fingers first, a gradual build, and stopping at the first sharp sensation rather than pushing through it are unglamorous but effective. Pain is information, and overriding it is how a manageable moment becomes a fissure that hurts for weeks.
When pain means an existing injury
If entry produces a sharp, tearing pain in the same spot each time, and you also get pain when opening your bowels with bright blood on the paper, that is an anal fissure and it will not resolve while you keep reopening it. A fissure needs a few weeks of healing, softer stools and often a prescribed ointment. Continuing to have receptive sex through it is the main reason fissures become chronic.
When pain suggests infection
A deep ache, a constant sore feeling, pain accompanied by discharge or a persistent urge to open your bowels with little result all point towards proctitis, which is inflammation of the rectal lining caused by gonorrhoea, chlamydia, lymphogranuloma venereum, herpes or mpox. This is not something to manage with more lubricant. It needs a rectal swab and treatment, and the treatments differ depending on which organism is involved.
What about drugs and numbing products?
Numbing lubricants and sprays are the single worst thing to use for anal pain. Pain is the mechanism that stops you causing damage, and removing it means injuries happen without you noticing until afterwards. The same applies to drugs that dull sensation during long sessions. If you need to numb something to do it, the honest answer is that the approach needs changing rather than the sensation.
When should you stop and get checked?
Stop immediately for severe pain, and see someone the same day for heavy bleeding, severe abdominal pain, fever, or an inability to pass wind or stool afterwards, all of which can indicate a perforation. Book a clinic appointment within the week for pain that lasts more than a few days, pain with discharge, or a tearing pain at the same spot each time.
What usually fixes it
More lubricant than feels necessary, a slower build, positions where the receptive partner controls depth and pace, warmth, and a partner who stops when asked without needing a reason. If pain persists despite all of that, it is a medical question rather than a technique question, and a sexual health clinic will examine the area and take swabs without making it awkward.
Does it get easier over time?
For most people, yes, though not because anything stretches permanently. What changes is familiarity: the internal sphincter tightens less when the situation is not novel, and you learn what your own body needs in terms of pace, position and quantity of lubricant. Anyone telling you that discomfort is simply something to get used to has it backwards. Sex that consistently hurts is sex that needs a different approach, not more tolerance.