Yes, somewhat. Pretending otherwise is one reason condom promotion has often failed to persuade anyone. What is worth knowing is that most of the sensation people lose comes from things that are fixable rather than from the presence of a barrier, and several of those things are easy to change.
The wrong size
The largest single factor. A condom that is too tight constricts and dulls sensation considerably, and one that is too loose slides rather than moving with you. Nominal width is the measurement that matters, and most people have never tried anything other than the standard fifty-two to fifty-four millimetres. Trying a snugger or wider fit changes the experience more than any other adjustment.
Not enough lubricant
The second largest. Friction against dry latex is unpleasant for both people and is also what causes breakage. Plenty of lubricant outside, and crucially a drop or two inside the tip before rolling it on, transforms how it feels. The inside drop is the single most underused piece of advice here.
Thickness
Thin and ultra-thin condoms transmit noticeably more sensation and heat, and used correctly with adequate lubricant they are not meaningfully more likely to break. Extra-thick varieties marketed for anal sex are unnecessary; lubrication does more for durability than material thickness.
Losing an erection
Common, and often more about the interruption than the condom. Putting it on as part of what is happening rather than as a pause helps, as does having one within reach rather than in another room. If it happens consistently, it is worth mentioning at a clinic, since erectile difficulties have treatable causes and are not a character issue.
What not to use
Numbing condoms and numbing lubricants reduce sensation deliberately, which is the opposite of what you want and removes the pain signal that prevents injury. Ribbed and studded textures add friction, which is not an advantage for anal sex. Spermicidal condoms damage the rectal lining and should be avoided entirely.
Does material make a difference?
Polyurethane is thinner than latex and conducts heat well, which many people prefer, though it is less elastic. Polyisoprene feels close to latex and suits people with an allergy. Trying a mixed pack costs little and settles the question better than any description can.
What about the receptive partner?
The differences are smaller from that side, and adequate lubrication matters more than anything else. Some people find the sensation of latex noticeable and prefer polyisoprene or polyurethane. Reduced friction from proper lubrication improves comfort considerably and reduces the microtears that cause soreness afterwards.
Is it worth persisting?
That is a decision rather than an instruction. Condoms cover infections that PrEP and vaccination do not, particularly gonorrhoea, herpes and mpox. Someone who has genuinely tried a better fit, more lubricant and a thinner material and still does not want to use them is making an informed choice, and the useful response is to make sure the rest of their prevention is in place rather than to keep arguing.
Is there a role for talking about it?
Some. If a partner knows that sensation is the sticking point, they may have their own solutions, and it is a more productive conversation than a general disagreement about whether to use one. It also opens the option of using them for part of a session rather than treating it as all or nothing.
The three changes worth making first
A different width, considerably more lubricant, and a drop inside the tip. Most people who describe condoms as unbearable have never tried all three.
Does putting it on differently help?
Pinching the tip to exclude air is the standard advice and also improves sensation, since trapped air dulls contact and concentrates pressure. Rolling it down fully rather than leaving it partly unrolled also matters, both for security and for how it feels.
What about warming it first?
Holding a condom in your hand for a few seconds before opening it takes the chill off, which some people find makes a noticeable difference. It costs nothing to try.