Checking a partner's phone is common, rarely discussed, and almost always makes the situation worse. It does not resolve the anxiety that prompted it, it introduces a breach on your side, and it substitutes evidence-gathering for a conversation you could have had.
Why does it not resolve anything?
Because finding nothing does not reassure for long. The absence of evidence becomes evidence of care in concealment, and the checking recurs. People who do this describe a cycle rather than an answer, with each search producing relief that lasts hours. It behaves like a compulsion because it is one.
What if you find something?
Then you have information obtained in a way you now have to account for, which frequently turns the conversation into an argument about the search rather than about what it found. It also removes the possibility of the other person having told you themselves, which matters more than people expect.
What is usually underneath it?
Anxiety, a specific unaddressed worry, or something you noticed and did not raise. The checking is a way of avoiding a difficult conversation, and the difficult conversation is what would actually help. If you have a specific concern, that is the thing to say.
What should you do instead?
Ask, once, plainly, about the specific thing. Are you seeing other people, or has anything happened I should know about, are answerable questions. Someone with a straightforward answer will give one. Someone who deflects, turns it around or makes you feel unreasonable for asking has told you something.
What if you cannot stop checking?
Worth treating as a problem in its own right rather than as a symptom of their behaviour. Compulsive checking is exhausting and self-reinforcing, and it persists even when the relationship is fine. Talking to someone about it is more useful than resolving to stop.
When is it the other way round?
Requiring access to a partner's phone, demanding passwords, tracking their location or inspecting their messages as an expectation is not a response to insecurity. It is monitoring, and it is a recognised element of controlling behaviour. Coercive control in a relationship is a criminal offence in the UK.
What about mutual openness?
Some couples share access and are entirely comfortable with it. The distinction is whether it is a choice both made or a condition one imposed. Agreeing to it because refusing would cause trouble is not agreement.
Does it ever help?
Very occasionally it confirms something important that was being concealed, and even then it usually confirms what the person already knew. The cost is that the conversation which follows starts from a worse position than it needed to.
What about health information?
Worth separating from everything else, since this is the one area where you genuinely need information. If you suspect a partner is not telling you about outside sex, the response is to test yourself at the correct intervals and to use condoms or PrEP, which protects you regardless of what is true. That works whether or not you ever find out.
Does it differ for a new relationship?
Early on there is usually less standing to expect access to anything, and the impulse is frequently strongest then because you know the person least. Asking directly is even more available at that stage, since the relationship has less invested in not having difficult conversations.
The practical position
Ask the question. If you cannot ask it, that is the problem to address, and it is a bigger one than whatever is on the phone.
What if you have already done it?
Deciding what to do next is the question rather than whether it was justified. Telling them is one option and produces a difficult conversation from a poor starting point. Not telling them and stopping is another, and it works better where it was a one-off rather than a habit.
What about shared accounts?
Different from covert checking. Couples who share location, accounts or devices by agreement are doing something mutual. The question is whether both of you chose it freely, and whether either of you could stop without it causing trouble.