Back to Community

What Rules Actually Work in Practice?

What Rules Actually Work in Practice?
Bareback Guide 23 November 2025

Rules in open relationships tend to fail in predictable ways. The ones that hold are few in number, specific enough to check against, and revisited rather than set once. The ones that collapse are elaborate, vague, or designed to prevent someone from having feelings.

What do couples commonly agree?

Not at home, or not in our bed. No repeat partners, or repeat partners only with agreement. No mutual friends or colleagues. No sleepovers. Condoms with everyone outside. Tell me beforehand, or tell me afterwards, or do not tell me. Not on nights we have plans. Each of these is checkable, which is why they work.

Why do vague rules fail?

Because nothing counts as breaking them until someone is upset, at which point the rule is retrospectively defined. Do not do anything that would hurt me sounds reasonable and is unenforceable, since neither of you knows in advance what that covers. Specific rules are kinder because they are knowable.

Why do elaborate rulebooks fail?

Because they attempt to legislate for every situation and cannot. A long list produces constant small breaches, each of which requires a conversation, and eventually people stop mentioning them. Three rules that are always observed work better than fifteen that are approximately followed.

What about rules against feelings?

Do not fall for anyone is the most common and the least achievable. You cannot agree not to feel something. What can be agreed is what you do about it: telling your partner, not pursuing it, or bringing it back to the couple for a conversation. Rules about behaviour hold; rules about emotion do not.

Which rules are about safety?

Condoms with people outside, testing every three months covering every site, and telling each other if a condom fails or a diagnosis arrives. These are different in kind from the others, since breaking them has consequences beyond feelings and beyond the two of you.

What about rules that only apply to one person?

Occasionally reasonable, often a sign that something is unbalanced. If one person has restrictions the other does not, it is worth being honest about whether that reflects genuinely different wants or a power imbalance in the relationship.

How do you know a rule is not working?

When it is being broken repeatedly, when it is being technically observed while the spirit is not, or when one of you is not mentioning things because of it. Rules that produce concealment are worse than no rule, because concealment is what damages relationships rather than the sex.

What should happen then?

Change it. Rules are tools rather than commitments, and a rule that no longer fits should be revised rather than defended. Couples who treat the terms as revisable manage considerably better than those who treat any change as a defeat.

How often should you review?

Every few months at first and at least annually afterwards, plus whenever circumstances change. A short scheduled conversation is far easier than raising something as a problem, and it makes adjustment ordinary.

Should rules be written down?

Worth doing informally. A short list in a message settles later disagreement about what was actually agreed, which happens more than people expect, and it makes the periodic review straightforward rather than a reconstruction.

What is the minimum?

What is allowed, what is not, what happens about condoms and testing, and what you tell each other. Four things, agreed specifically, will carry most couples further than an elaborate document.

What if a rule is broken immediately?

Usually a sign the rule was wrong rather than that the person is unreliable. Rules agreed in the abstract frequently turn out to be impractical the first time they meet reality, and revising them is the appropriate response rather than enforcement.

Do rules need to be symmetrical?

Not necessarily, and asymmetry is worth examining. Different rules for each person can reflect genuinely different wants and can also reflect one person having more say. The test is whether both of you would describe the arrangement the same way.