One person wanting an open relationship and the other not is among the most common difficulties couples bring to this, and it is frequently handled badly by both. The version that goes worst is where the reluctant partner eventually agrees to end the conversation.
Why does that not work?
Because agreement obtained by persistence is not agreement. Someone who consents to avoid conflict, or because they fear losing the relationship, is tolerating rather than choosing, and the resentment that follows tends to attach to everything rather than to the arrangement. The first outside encounter frequently produces a reaction out of proportion to what was agreed.
What does that look like from the other side?
Raising it once is a conversation. Raising it repeatedly, going quiet when refused, framing the refusal as controlling, or implying the relationship cannot continue otherwise is pressure. Most people applying it would not describe it that way, which is precisely why it is worth naming.
What is worth understanding first?
What each of you actually wants, which is usually more specific than the headline. Wanting more sex, wanting variety, wanting freedom, wanting to stop feeling constrained and wanting a particular person are different wants with different implications. So is the objection: fear of losing you, fear of comparison, a moral position, or simply not wanting to.
Are there middle positions?
Several, and worth exploring before treating it as binary. Occasional rather than ongoing. Only together. Only while travelling. A defined trial period with a review date. These suit some couples and they are not a solution where the objection is fundamental rather than about degree.
What about a trial?
Reasonable if it is genuinely a trial, with an agreed end date and a real option to stop. It is not reasonable if the expectation is that the reluctant partner will get used to it. The difference is whether no remains an available answer at the end.
What if the answer is settled?
Then you have a genuine incompatibility, and that is a legitimate reason for a relationship to end. It is not a failure on either side and neither position is wrong. Staying together while one person permanently wants something the other will never agree to produces slow damage.
What about doing it anyway?
That is not an open relationship; it is an affair, and the damage comes from the concealment rather than the sex. If you have already done it, the health steps matter first: testing at the correct intervals and telling your partner so they can test too.
What if you are the reluctant one?
You are allowed to say no permanently, and you are allowed to change your mind. You are also allowed to ask for time rather than an answer. What is worth avoiding is agreeing to something you do not want in order to end a difficult conversation, since that produces a worse one later.
Does counselling help?
Often, particularly where the conversation has become circular. A counsellor familiar with non-monogamy will not treat either position as the problem, which matters, since a therapist who regards the request as pathology or the refusal as repression is unhelpful. Pink Therapy holds a directory of therapists who work with LGBT clients.
What is the honest framing?
This is a question about compatibility rather than about who is being unreasonable. Both wants are legitimate and they may not fit together, and finding that out is better than one person quietly giving way.
What if the request comes after something already happened?
Two separate conversations that frequently get conflated. What happened needs addressing on its own terms, including testing, before any discussion of changing the arrangement. Proposing an open relationship as a response to having broken a closed one usually reads as retrospective permission.
Is wanting it a sign of something wrong?
Not in itself. A great many people in happy relationships want sex with other people, and it is common enough to be unremarkable. Where it is a symptom rather than a want, that usually shows in what else is going on.