Back to Community

Is Don't Ask Don't Tell a Good Idea?

Is Don't Ask Don't Tell a Good Idea?
Bareback Guide 22 December 2025

Don't ask don't tell means sex outside the relationship is permitted and not discussed. It is common, it genuinely suits some couples, and it produces one specific problem that is worth understanding before choosing it.

What does it solve?

The management of detail. For people who find hearing about a partner's encounters distressing, or who find themselves asking questions they wish they had not, removing the conversation removes a recurring source of difficulty. It also protects a certain amount of privacy that some people value.

What does it create?

An information gap with health consequences. If one of you is exposed to something, the other has no way of knowing to test. If a condom fails, there is no mechanism to raise it. If a diagnosis arrives, telling your partner means breaching the arrangement, which is exactly the moment when the arrangement most needs breaching.

How do couples handle that?

With an exception clause, which is the version that works. Nothing is discussed except three things: a condom failure, a diagnosis, and a possible HIV exposure. Those are specific, rare and time-limited, and building them in from the start means nobody has to decide whether this is the moment to break the rule.

What about routine testing?

Agree it explicitly as part of the arrangement. Both of you screening every three months covering every site, regardless of what has happened, means neither of you has to disclose anything to justify a test. This is probably the single most useful adjustment available to couples in this arrangement.

What about PrEP?

Worth both of you being on it, or at least the partner having outside sex, since it removes HIV from the equation without requiring any conversation. It also means an unreported exposure is not a crisis. Vaccination for hepatitis A and B, HPV and mpox does similar work.

Does it hide problems?

Sometimes. The arrangement can be genuine mutual preference, and it can also be a way of avoiding a conversation neither person wants to have about what is actually going on. Worth being honest with yourself about which it is, since one is a working structure and the other is deferral.

What does it require to work?

Trust that the agreed limits are being observed without any means of verifying it. That is a considerable amount of trust, and couples who manage it well are usually those who were solid before rather than those hoping the arrangement will produce stability.

Who does it suit?

Couples where one or both genuinely do not want detail, where the outside sex is casual rather than ongoing, and where both people are reliable about health measures without being reminded. It suits less well where one person is anxious, since the absence of information tends to be filled with imagination.

Can you change it?

Yes, in either direction, and it is worth revisiting. Some couples start with disclosure and move to this because the detail was not helping; others do the reverse because the silence became isolating. Neither shift is a failure.

Does it work with a regular outside partner?

Less well. The arrangement suits casual encounters, where there is little to tell. A recurring partner accumulates a presence in someone's life that silence does not accommodate easily, and couples frequently find this is the point at which the arrangement needs revisiting.

What is the minimum to agree?

What is permitted, that condoms are used outside or that both of you are on PrEP, that both of you screen every three months, and the three exceptions where you do tell each other. That makes the arrangement workable rather than merely quiet.

Does it make partner notification harder?

Yes, and this is the practical consequence people miss. If you are diagnosed with something, your partner needs telling regardless of the arrangement, and outside partners need notifying too. Clinics do that anonymously, so the mechanism exists; what the arrangement removes is the prompt.

What if you want to change it?

Say so rather than starting to volunteer information, which lands as a breach even though it is more open. Renegotiating explicitly is the version that works.