Jealousy is not evidence that an open relationship is wrong, and it is not something to be eliminated by sufficient enlightenment. It is a signal, and the useful work is finding out what it is pointing at, which is usually more specific than the feeling suggests.
What is it usually about?
Rarely the sex itself. More often it is about time, attention, being replaceable, or a fear about the relationship's future. Someone upset that their partner spent Saturday with someone else is frequently not upset about the sex but about the Saturday. That distinction matters because the two have different solutions.
How do you find the specific thing?
By asking what exactly you are picturing when the feeling arrives. It is usually a particular detail: staying over, a repeat visit, a photograph, someone you know, laughing together. Identifying it turns an unmanageable feeling into something that can be discussed and often accommodated with a small change.
What do you do with it?
Say it, without requiring it to be justified. I felt awful on Saturday and I think it was about being alone is information your partner can respond to. Presenting it as an argument against the arrangement usually produces a defence rather than a response.
What should the other person do?
Listen rather than reassure immediately. Reassurance offered too quickly closes the conversation before the specific thing has been identified, and the feeling returns. Asking what would have made it easier is more useful than insisting it means nothing.
Does it go away?
Usually it reduces considerably with familiarity, particularly the anticipatory version, which is frequently worse than the reality. The first few occasions are the hardest for almost everyone. Most couples who report it settling describe the change happening over months rather than weeks.
What is compersion?
A term for taking pleasure in a partner's enjoyment with someone else. Some people experience it, some do not, and it is not a standard to be measured against. Not feeling it does not mean you are doing this badly; treating its absence as a failure adds a burden that nobody needs.
What helps practically?
Knowing when something is happening rather than being surprised by it. Having something of your own that evening. Agreeing what you will do afterwards, including whether you want contact. Small structural adjustments do more than resolving to feel differently.
When is it structural rather than emotional?
If the arrangement genuinely does not suit you, jealousy is an accurate signal rather than a problem to be managed. Persistent, unrelieved distress over months is worth taking at face value. The willingness to be open is not a virtue that outranks your own wellbeing.
What about jealousy on the other side?
Frequently unspoken, particularly where one person proposed the arrangement and feels they cannot admit difficulty. Asking directly rather than assuming enthusiasm is worth doing, since resentment builds quietly in the person who thought they were fine.
What about anticipatory jealousy?
Usually worse than the reality, which is worth knowing in advance. The evening before frequently produces more distress than the evening itself, and people who have been through it several times consistently report the anticipation fading faster than anything else.
When is outside help useful?
If the same conversation recurs without resolution, if it is affecting how you function, or if it sits alongside broader anxiety. Relationship counselling that is familiar with non-monogamy exists and is considerably more useful than a counsellor who treats the structure as the diagnosis. Pink Therapy holds a directory of therapists who work with LGBT clients.
Does it help to know less?
For some people, considerably. Others find that less information produces more imagining, which is worse. This is worth testing rather than assuming, and the answer frequently differs from what people expect about themselves.
What about jealousy of a specific person?
More common than general jealousy and usually about something identifiable: that they see your partner regularly, that they have something you do not, or that they occupy a place you wanted. Naming the specific thing makes it discussable in a way that a general feeling is not.