Back to Bareback

Why Do People Underestimate Their Own Risk?

Why Do People Underestimate Their Own Risk?
Bareback Guide 12 November 2025

People are consistently poor at estimating their own risk, and the ways in which they are wrong follow predictable patterns. Recognising the mechanisms is more useful than being told to be careful, because the mechanisms operate whether or not you have been warned about them.

Optimism bias

Most people rate their own risk as below average for almost anything, which is arithmetically impossible across a population. It applies to sexual health as it applies to driving and to health generally. The bias is stronger for outcomes that feel controllable, and sex feels controllable in a way that, for infection purposes, it largely is not.

The absence of consequences

Someone who has had condomless sex for years without a diagnosis draws a reasonable-seeming inference that their approach works. The inference fails for two reasons: most infections cause nothing you would notice, so an absence of symptoms is not an absence of infection, and past outcomes say little about future ones when the underlying rate is a matter of chance across many encounters.

Familiarity with partners

Risk feels lower with someone you know, someone you have seen before, or someone you like. None of those correlate with their infection status. This is one of the strongest and least examined effects: people routinely use condoms with strangers and not with a regular partner whose recent testing they have never discussed.

Judging by appearance

Nobody believes they do this and a great many people do. Someone who looks healthy, is well presented and speaks confidently reads as lower risk. Every infection discussed on this site is compatible with looking entirely well, and most are silent by default.

Confusing HIV risk with all risk

Someone on PrEP has genuinely removed HIV from the picture, and it is easy for that to shade into a general feeling of being covered. PrEP does nothing about gonorrhoea, chlamydia, syphilis, herpes, hepatitis or mpox, which are the infections most people actually acquire. The protection is real and specific.

The single-encounter frame

Any one act carries a small probability. The relevant number is what accumulates across a year, and small probabilities repeated many times become substantial. People assess the evening in front of them rather than the pattern, which is a reasonable way to live and a poor way to estimate risk.

What corrects for all this?

Systems rather than judgement. Screening on a fixed calendar interval rather than when concerned, since the concern signal is exactly the thing that is unreliable. PrEP taken continuously rather than assessed encounter by encounter. Vaccination courses completed, which need no judgement at all once done.

Does knowing about the bias help?

Somewhat, and less than you would hope. Being aware of optimism bias does not remove it. What works better is removing the need to judge: a reminder in a calendar, a daily tablet and a completed vaccine course all operate regardless of how you assess a given night.

The useful conclusion

Assume your instinct is running low, and build a plan that does not depend on it being accurate.

Does it work the other way for some people?

Yes. Health anxiety produces the opposite distortion, where very low risks feel enormous and reassurance wears off within hours. That is a different problem with a different solution, and the answer there is a plan with dates in it rather than more information.

What about the influence of other people?

Strong and largely invisible. If nobody in your circle mentions being diagnosed, the rate feels lower than it is, since people who acquire infections are less likely to talk about it. Perception of what is normal in a group tends to be built from what is said aloud rather than what happens.

Does experience help?

Less than expected, because the feedback is poor. Most infections produce no signal, so years of condomless sex without a diagnosis teaches nothing reliable about whether the approach works.